Watercolour illustration of a woman reconsidering her to-do list for What Am I Doing Because I Think I Should?, Reflection 07 of The Life I’m Living Collection.
Intentional living,  Midlife Reflections,  Printables,  Slow and Intentional Living

What Am I Doing Because I Think I Should?

There are some things we do because they need to be done.

There are responsibilities we have chosen, commitments we have made and people we care about. There are bills to pay, homes to look after, work to do, appointments to keep and ordinary jobs that are simply part of being an adult.

But then there are all the other things.

The things we do because somewhere along the way we absorbed the idea that this is what we should do.

We should keep the house a certain way. We should answer messages quickly. We should accept the invitation. We should make the effort. We should be productive with our time. We should cook properly. We should remember birthdays. We should keep everyone connected. We should make Christmas magical, holidays memorable and weekends worthwhile.

We should be interested. Available. Helpful. Grateful.

We should cope.

And perhaps one of the strangest things about these little rules is that we can live by them for years without ever really asking ourselves where they came from.

So this reflection isn’t about becoming irresponsible, abandoning the people who rely on us or deciding that we never have to do anything we don’t particularly fancy doing.

It’s simply about noticing.

How much of what I do is because I genuinely choose to do it — and how much is because I’ve somehow decided that I should?

The rules we never consciously made

Most of us probably couldn’t sit down and tell you exactly when we decided how a good life should look.

We picked it up along the way.

From our families. From the homes we grew up in. From school and work. From friendships and relationships. From our communities and culture. From things people said casually years ago that somehow stayed with us.

And increasingly, of course, from the endless stream of other people’s lives we see online.

We learn what a good mother does. What a good friend does. What a successful person does. What a lovely home looks like. How often we should exercise. What we should eat. How productive our mornings should be. What our children should experience. How our relationships should look. How much we should achieve and how gracefully we should apparently manage all of it.

Very few of these things arrive labelled RULE.

They are much quieter than that.

They become little assumptions about what is normal, expected or admirable.

And eventually they become sentences that begin with:

I really should…

Some of our shoulds once made perfect sense

I think this is important, because the aim isn’t to look back at all the expectations we’ve carried and decide we’ve somehow been foolish for carrying them.

Some of our shoulds were once completely appropriate.

Perhaps there was a time when you genuinely wanted to volunteer for everything at school. Maybe hosting everyone at your house brought you enormous pleasure. Perhaps keeping a meticulously organised home made life feel calm. Maybe you loved a packed social calendar. Perhaps working late was worthwhile while you were building something important.

Maybe you were the person who organised every family gathering because you genuinely enjoyed doing it.

Things change.

Lives change.

Energy changes.

People change.

And sometimes the problem isn’t the thing itself. It’s that we never stopped to ask whether it still fits.

We can continue following rules created by a version of ourselves who lived a completely different life.

That doesn’t make the old choice wrong.

It simply means it might be time to choose again.

There is a difference between responsibility and obligation

Of course, not every should is something we can simply stop doing.

There are responsibilities in life. Sometimes we show up because somebody needs us, not because it’s convenient. We do jobs we’d rather avoid. We honour commitments. We care for people. We make compromises. We do things because they matter to someone we love.

A meaningful life isn’t one in which we only ever do exactly what we want.

But there is a difference between a genuine responsibility and an obligation we’ve quietly created for ourselves.

Sometimes it’s worth asking:

What would actually happen if I didn’t do this?

Not what would I feel might happen.

What would really happen?

Would somebody genuinely be hurt?

Would something important be neglected?

Would I be breaking a commitment I actually want to honour?

Or would somebody perhaps be mildly disappointed?

Would something simply be done differently?

Would another capable person eventually do it themselves?

Would nobody even notice?

Would the only uncomfortable thing be that I would have to tolerate the feeling that I hadn’t done what I usually do?

That can be a very revealing distinction.

The ‘shoulds’ around caring for other people

For many of us, some of the strongest expectations are tied to the people we love.

We want to be there.

We want to help.

We want people to know they can rely on us.

And there is something deeply good about that.

But being a caring person doesn’t mean we have to take responsibility for everybody’s comfort.

It doesn’t mean we must always be the one who remembers, organises, checks in, smooths things over, makes the plan, brings the thing, notices the problem and quietly sorts it out.

It doesn’t mean every request requires a yes.

And it doesn’t mean somebody else’s disappointment automatically means we’ve done something wrong.

Sometimes we continue doing something because we’ve become the person who does it.

Everyone expects it.

Perhaps we expect it of ourselves most of all.

And changing that can feel surprisingly uncomfortable.

But there may be things you have been doing for years that another person could now do perfectly well.

There may be help you can offer without taking over.

There may be relationships in which you can care deeply without carrying the entire responsibility for maintaining them.

There may be people you love enormously whose problems you cannot solve.

We don’t have to stop caring.

Sometimes we simply need to reconsider what caring requires of us.

Sometimes the pressure is entirely our own

This may be the trickiest kind of should because there is nobody else to blame for it.

Nobody has told us the house must be immaculate before someone visits.

Nobody cares whether the birthday cake is homemade.

Nobody is checking whether we used the weekend productively.

Nobody expects us to answer that email tonight.

Nobody has demanded that we make every family occasion special.

And yet there we are, putting enormous pressure on ourselves.

Sometimes we’re living according to standards nobody actually asked us to meet.

And perhaps there is something freeing about recognising that.

Because if we created the rule, we’re allowed to rewrite it.

Dinner can be simple.

The house can look lived in.

The message can wait.

You can buy the cake.

You can decline the invitation without producing an elaborate explanation.

You can spend the afternoon doing something that achieves absolutely nothing.

You can decide that something you used to do beautifully will now be done adequately.

Nothing terrible has happened.

Life has simply been allowed to be a little easier.

Watch for the should that is really comparison

Sometimes I should actually means:

Other people seem to be doing this, so perhaps I should be doing it too.

We see somebody else’s morning routine and suddenly ours seems inadequate.

Someone renovates their home and we begin noticing everything wrong with ours.

Somebody starts a new hobby, changes career, runs a marathon, travels somewhere wonderful, has an enviably active social life or appears to have an extraordinarily close extended family.

And without necessarily wanting any of those things five minutes earlier, we begin wondering whether we should want them.

That is worth noticing.

Because there is an enormous difference between being inspired by someone else’s life and using it as evidence that our own is lacking.

Something can be wonderful for them without needing to become part of our lives.

Their choice doesn’t have to become our should.

Your Free The Should List Printable

I’ve created a simple The Should List reflection printable to accompany this piece.

This one begins by getting those quiet expectations out of your head and onto the page.

The things you think you should do.

The person you think you should be.

The things you should care about, keep up with, say yes to, achieve, maintain or manage.

Don’t edit the list while you’re writing it.

Even if something sounds ridiculous once it’s on paper, write it down.

Especially then.

Because once we can see the rule, we can begin to question it.

The printable then invites you to look at each should a little more closely:

Where did this come from?

Do I actually believe it?

Does it still fit my life now?

Is it a genuine responsibility — or an expectation I’ve been carrying?

And finally:

Do I want to keep it, change it or let it go?

This isn’t about trying to eliminate every obligation from your life.

It’s about deciding which ones are actually yours.

The Should List free reflection printable for exploring expectations, responsibilities and the things we do because we think we should.

How to use this reflection

Start by listening for the word should in your own thoughts.

I should really…

At my age I should…

A good parent should…

I should be able to…

I should probably say yes…

I shouldn’t mind…

I should have sorted this by now…

Write them down.

Then choose one or two rather than trying to analyse everything at once.

Ask yourself where the expectation came from. Perhaps it reflects something you genuinely value. If so, keep it. The point isn’t to reject something simply because it contains the word should.

But perhaps you’ll realise you’re maintaining a standard that doesn’t matter to you anymore.

Maybe you’re doing something because you’ve always done it.

Perhaps you’re worried about disappointing someone.

Perhaps you’re comparing yourself with people whose lives are entirely different from yours.

Maybe you’re trying to meet an expectation nobody has actually placed on you.

And perhaps the answer isn’t stop.

It might simply be:

Do it differently.

Do it less often.

Ask for help.

Lower the standard.

Share the responsibility.

Say no occasionally.

Let somebody else decide.

Allow good enough to be enough.

Or, where it truly doesn’t belong anymore, let it go.

You don’t need to replace every should with a new rule

There is one little trap I’d like us to avoid here.

We don’t need to become so determined to live authentically and intentionally that not doing things because we should becomes yet another thing we should be doing perfectly.

That rather defeats the purpose.

You will still do things out of duty sometimes.

You will still say yes when you’d rather stay home because the person asking matters to you.

You’ll occasionally clean the house before someone visits even though you know perfectly well they don’t care.

You’ll keep traditions simply because they’ve always been yours.

You’ll make an unnecessary effort because it brings somebody else joy.

That’s life.

The question isn’t whether every choice is completely free from obligation.

It’s whether too much of your life is being directed by expectations you’ve never stopped to examine.

You are allowed to choose again

Perhaps that’s what I want this reflection to leave us with.

We are allowed to revisit the rules.

We can appreciate why something mattered once and decide it matters less now.

We can care about people without always making ourselves responsible for them.

We can change how we do things.

We can lower standards that have become unnecessarily exhausting.

We can disappoint someone occasionally and survive the discomfort of that.

We can decide that an expectation we inherited doesn’t belong to us.

And sometimes we can simply say:

I don’t actually want to do this anymore.

Not dramatically.

Not angrily.

Not because the old way was wrong.

Just because we’re paying attention to the life we’re living now.

And perhaps one of the quietest ways we make space in that life is by noticing the things we keep doing because we think we should — and giving ourselves permission to decide, consciously and kindly, whether we still want to.


Continue Reflecting

Previous: What Do I Want Less of in My Life?

Return to Reflection 06 and consider what may be taking up more time, energy, attention or importance than you want to give it — and what making it a little smaller could create room for.

Next: What Have I Outgrown?

Continue with Reflection 08 as we explore the routines, expectations, ambitions, roles and old versions of ourselves that may once have fitted beautifully — but perhaps don’t belong quite so comfortably in the life we’re living now.

Explore The Life I’m Living Collection →

Explore the complete collection of thoughtful reflections and free printables designed to help you slow down, check in with yourself and pay a little more attention to the life you’re living now.

Chat soon,

Ciara x

Before You Go…

Looking for a little extra inspiration?

Browse our growing collection of free printables, including seasonal calendars, bucket lists, planners, journals and reflection pages designed to help you create a slower, more intentional life.

Browse the Printable Library

Subscribe to Our Little Friday Letter

Visit us on Instagram

Printable FAQs

Is this printable free?

Yes. All of the printables are free to download for personal use. You can print just the pages that speak to you, or work your way through the complete collection over time.

What size are the printables?

The printables are designed primarily for A4 paper, which is the standard paper size used in Ireland, the UK and many other countries. If you’re printing on US Letter paper, select Fit to Page or your printer’s equivalent setting and the design should resize neatly to fit.

Occasionally, a reflection may work better in landscape format. Where this is the case, it will be clearly indicated on the individual printable.

Do I need to complete the collection in order?

Not at all. The Life I’m Living Collection has been thoughtfully arranged so that the reflections can naturally lead from one to another, but there is no right way to use it.

You can begin with the question that feels most relevant to you today, move through the collection in order, or simply return to individual pages whenever you need them.

Do I need to answer every question?

No. These pages are invitations rather than assignments.

Some prompts may immediately give you something to write about, while others may not feel particularly relevant to the season of life you’re in. Write a sentence, fill a page, leave something blank or come back to it another day.

There is nothing to complete and no score to achieve.

Can I use the printables as journal prompts instead?

Absolutely. You don’t have to write directly onto the printable. You can use any of the questions or prompts as starting points for longer reflections in your own notebook or journal.

You might also find that one small question gives you far more to think about than the space provided on the page. Follow it wherever it takes you.

Can I print the pages more than once?

Yes. For your own personal use, you can print the pages again whenever you’d like to revisit a reflection.

In fact, returning to some of these questions six months or a year from now could be particularly interesting. Our answers change as our lives do.

Can I put all of the printables together in a binder?

Yes — and the collection has been deliberately designed with that in mind.

Although the individual layouts vary depending on the reflection, the pages share the same cream, navy, antique-gold and blue-and-white visual style so that they form one cohesive journal when collected together.

🖨️ Create Your Binder

If you’re planning to print several of our printables in this collection, a few simple supplies can make it easy to create your own beautiful binder to enjoy year after year.

(This section contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Our Little House in the Country.)

Can I share these printables with someone else?

You’re very welcome to share the link to the relevant blog post or collection page so that friends, family or your online community can download their own copy.

Please don’t upload, email, reproduce or redistribute the PDF files themselves.

Can I use these printables in a group, class or workshop?

The printables are created primarily for personal use. If you’d like to use one as part of a class, workshop, group or other organised setting, please contact me first so we can make sure it is being used appropriately and with full credit to Our Little House in the Country.

What are the terms of use?

All Our Little House in the Country printables are provided for personal use only unless specific permission has been given otherwise.

Please do not sell, reproduce, alter for resale, upload, distribute or include the printable files in your own digital or physical products. If you’d like to recommend a printable to someone else, please share the original page on Our Little House in the Country rather than the PDF itself.

You can read the complete Printables Terms of Use for further information.


  • The Beautiful Art of Anticipation
    Christmas magic isn’t only found on Christmas Day. Explore a heartfelt reflection on anticipation, changing family traditions, festive preparations and finding joy in the weeks leading up to Christmas. From Our Little House in the Country.
  • Knowing When You’ve Done Enough
    There is always something else we could be doing. Another improvement, another plan, another thing to organise. But what if we’ve already done enough? A personal reflection on perfectionism, getting older, letting go of unnecessary pressure and learning to enjoy the life we’ve worked so hard to create.
  • What Are You Filling Your Life With?
    What are we filling our lives with? A reflection on attention, ordinary goodness and learning to notice what deserves more room in the lives we’re already living.
  • A Slower Life, Right in the Middle of a Full One
    Slow living doesn’t necessarily mean having a slow life. An autumn reflection on intentional living, seasonal rhythms, full family days and learning to notice the life that’s already happening around us.
  • When the Days Feel Like Themselves Again
    There’s something lovely about summer days losing their edges. But as autumn returns, I’m rediscovering the quiet comfort of the week finding its shape again — Friday feeling like Friday, Sunday feeling like Sunday, and ordinary life settling back into its familiar rhythm.

Watercolour Christmas country home with snowy countryside, evergreen greenery, dried oranges, candles and blue-and-white pottery.

🌿 Enjoyed this post?

If you enjoy slow living reflections, seasonal inspiration, and life from our little house in the country, you might enjoy Our Little Friday Letter.

It’s a gentle email sent every second Friday morning — no noise, no spam, just thoughtful reflections and seasonal living.

You’re very welcome to join us.

Welcome to Our Little House in the Country

You can unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox — no spam, ever.! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Watercolour Christmas country home with snowy countryside, evergreen greenery, dried oranges, candles and blue-and-white pottery.

🌿 Enjoyed this post?

If you enjoy slow living reflections, seasonal inspiration, and life from our little house in the country, you might enjoy Our Little Friday Letter.

It’s a gentle email sent every second Friday morning — no noise, no spam, just thoughtful reflections and seasonal living.

You’re very welcome to join us.

Welcome to Our Little House in the Country

You can unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox — no spam, ever.! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Hi, I’m Ciara — writer, homemaker, and the heart behind Our Little House in the Country. I share slow, seasonal living from our cozy corner of the Irish countryside, where life is a little messy, a little magical, and deeply real. Whether it’s a teen-friendly recipe, a lived-in home moment, or a reminder to let go of perfection, this space is about embracing the everyday and finding joy in what’s already here. Come in, kick off your shoes, and stay a while — the kettle’s always on.